That is a very good question. There are more questions than I think
answers here. One is "what is the long term effect of a ride" and how
long does it last. When can we say "a incident of colic or fatality is
not ride related, one day, two days, one week, etc?" That is what is
the period of the risk. It's interesting that we are now seeing more
fatalities being uncovered related to horse racing after people started
looking harder.
As far as the AERC, if a rider takes the horse home the day of a ride
and he develops colic the next day and dies three days later, there are
several questions.
1. Would the AERC know about it?
2. How should the AERC track such things?
3. Is it directly related to the ride, is it from the trailer ride, etc?
...
Truman
Barb Kemerer wrote:
I know we have to go with the statistics that are available and I
believe Truman used the day of and day after the ride. What about
those people who finish the ride (25 and 50s) and throw their horse on
the trailer and go home. It seems like this is becoming more prevalent
at least in the Northeast.
Barb Kemerer
Truman,
I by no means am a statistician, nor a mathematician, nor a
physicist -- or even a good speller. But I would like to know if
this makes a difference. When you are looking at the death rates
from the comparison study, are they not based on individual horses
only counted once in a given time frame, and when you are looking
at AERC stats you may be counting the same horse multiple times,
across multiple years? Does that really make a good comparison?
If not which way would it skew the results?
thanx eric
Eric Rueter
Rueter Consulting, Inc.
Eric@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx <mailto:Eric@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
865.988.4134(W)
865.599.3594(C)
865.986.5966(H)
This paper documents an analysis of the fatality rate of deaths
associated with AERC rides. The fatalities for the years of
2003 through
2007 are
considered. The reason to look at this question now is with in
excess of
110,000 starts in
this five year period, the sample size is sufficient to
statistically
differentiate small
proportions with a reasonable confidence. The data
are analyzed with the AERC fatalities broken into four
categories. The
first is all the
fatalities. The second is the fatalities in the one day 100
mile events.
The third is the
fatalities in the "fifty" mile events (all rides except one
day 100 and
LD rides). The final
category is LD. The question of do horses die at a higher
proportion as
a result of colic in
endurance that in the general population is also addressed.