Home Current News News Archive Shop/Advertise Ridecamp Classified Events Learn/AERC
Endurance.Net Home Ridecamp Archives
ridecamp@endurance.net
[Archives Index]   [Date Index]   [Thread Index]   [Author Index]   [Subject Index]

Re: [RC] [RC] Cloning - Crysta Turnage

I would disagree with this statement.  Unfortunately, the high cost of cloning may NOT mean that the best PERFORMANCE traits are passed on, but rather the traits of where the most money is at, which for many US breeds tends to be the showring.  I would hate to see HYPP positive horses cloned, that is certainly not a desirable breed trait that should be passed on, but HYPP N/H and even H/H horses often do very well in the QH halter ring and there's a lot of $$ there.  Or what about the latest "fashionable" Arab TREND being duplicated and passed on and on.  Certainly producing a clone would allow an individual to more or less double the length of their breeding career, allowing them to pass on their genetics for many more potential mates for years to come.  This starts to somewhat follow the line/thinking of doing embryo-transfer for mares...  allowing the individual to produce offspring (or more as the case may be) when nature or circumstance (such as Cash being gelded) may have dicated otherwise.
 
Also, Rusty brings up a great point with the Registries.  This clone and Cash have the same DNA - how would a registry tell them apart?  Particularly if the clone was of a currently breeding stallion or mare.  It would be impossible to DNA-type the offspring and to tell if the parent was the original or the clone.  How WOULD you register such an animal???
 
~ Crysta

 
On 10/24/07, Smith, Dave <dsmith@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

In response to Rusty's statement: "We as yet have no idea what this will do long term to the breed, life or quality of life of these animals…" I beg to differ.  Cloning large mammals has been around for more than a decade now and we have overwhelming evidence that cloned mammals live as long a and have as high a quality of life as any others of their kind.  As far as what cloning means to the breed, it will almost certainly improve the breed's gene pool since the high cost of cloning means only the best of the breed will be cloned.  Thus, horses with desirable qualities, such as high endurance, will increasingly be bred thanks to cloning which will improve the gene pool for the entire breed. 




--
~ Crysta

"Those of us who finish near the back, make the rest of you look good."
Replies
[RC] Cloning, Smith, Dave