With such nice round feet, you’d probably do just fine
in the plain easyboot, without the gaiters. Since you’ve already
purchased the Bares, I’m sure someone like Karen or others will be able
to help you find ways to make them work and answer your questions better.
I think you definitely need the size 1’s – you probably don’t
want to be able to put your finger in the boot, otherwise it is too big.
I personally like the old style EasyBoots the best –
not the new ones with the slit tongue, or any of the gaitered boots with the
slit tongue. With a round hoof and a little bit of heel, I have very
little problems with the old boots coming off. But I have lots of gaiters
with missing boots! And I’ve had no luck at all keeping any of the
boots on once they’re missing the gaiter because of that new tongue style
(at least that is my evaluation on what the problems is).
Aside from a round hoof and at least a little bit of heel,
the other hoof shape that helps keep boots on is a conical shape – ie slanted
side hoof walls, not real vertical. We loaned a boot this past weekend to
a guy on an AQHA ride and he kept losing it (finally permanently) while we had
few problems in rocks and bogs, and that was the major difference.