 |
Re: [RC] Injectable glucosamine vs. brand name Adequan - Jennifer ThompsonHi Roger,Thanks for all of the great info! One question though..I was always under the impression that Adequan was a glucosamine product, not chondroitin. Are yo certain about it being chondroitin? I went to their product info page and it says that Adequan is "polysulfated glycosaminoglycan" - so is that chondroitin or glucosamine, or maybe a little of both? Still undecided, Jennifer Roger Rittenhouse wrote: I too have been dealing with this again. There are a few studies that I read in THE HORSE that does support the use oral glucosamine but it is limited. MOST studies say the use of oral CS is not really worth it since only about 20% is absorbed. The best product for joint lubrication and protection is ADEQUAN. It has been proven to work in many studies. ADEQUAN is IM chondroitin sulfate, it is NOT the same as GL The look alike product CHRONOPROTEC is suppose to be the same, however 'studies' indicate it does not work as well. I think these studies came from the ADEQUAN mfgr. I have used CHRONOPROTEC and ADEQUAN both appear to work. My test subject is 26 yr old with many miles of work and some joint issues. I have used the GL IM but was sure it was as good. It is difficult to tell IF the substance really works , that to help create good joint lubrication to act as a preventative agent vs one that will correct damage in a horse with known joint issues. My old mare is sound but has reduced flexion and range of motion. If I leave her off any joint product for a month then ride her I can feel the difference. The put her back on it again and in a week she is back to moving very free and easy. Sure would of liked to had these product back when she was doing rides, I would have reduced the amount of joint damage due to the use. CHRONOPORTEC is about 1/2 the cost. I get a 2x dose for $52. If I buy more I get it for less. There is an injectable IM GL that I have used but was advised it does not work as well. However many riders are using it since it is obtained from an endurance vet. I have NOT read any study to show if the IM GLU works or not. Just riders who use it and get proven results. I do not remember the cost but it was reasonable. I think I will keep feeding the oral GLU pure product. I use HCL I get it from UCKELE. I will give the ADEQUAN I have (4) then go back to the CHRONOPROTEC. I will hold my decision to use IM GL until I find more data and studies to show me its works as well as the IM CS (ADEQUEN). Roger Rittenhouse www.vmaxept.com 800 655 8629 pictures http://community.webshots.com/user/psdenduranceFrom: Jennifer Thompson <jlthompson@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Subject:s Hi all, After listening to Dr. Garlinghouse's talk on supplements at convention (can't remember if it was the AERC or NATRC talk) and recently discussing joint supplements with her in person, I have decided to forego purchasing any more oral joint supplements, as none of them have ever really been scientifically proven to work, and just go with monthly IM injections of Adequan. I was shocked, however, at how much the price of Adequan has gone up since the last time I used it (it's now $60 to $70 per one-dose vial!), and am now looking into similar products I've been seeing adverstised, labeled as just plain old "injectable glucosamine".============================================================ People in Alabama swear by manure tea as an herbal remedy for colds. ~ Lisa Redmond ridecamp.net information: http://www.endurance.net/ridecamp/ ============================================================
|