Hi Jen-
I guess you have solved the sore butt problem, and are now working on your
feet ! Seems like some part always hurts ! I used boots, then riding
sneakers, ( horseshoes, Ropers, etc. ) and now I will only ride in Saucony
cross trainer type sneakers. There are many types available- I go to Big 5
and get something in last season's colors. They all look the same to me,
especially after they get dusty ! They have a wider toe box that makes me
very happy ! I use a pair of calf high cotton socks, then my suede half
chaps and I am a happy woman ! The plus is that some models have a bit of a
grid for super traction if you get off and run or walk. I use Easy Rider
stirrups, so I feel safe w/ these. Good Luck !! - Heidi Helly